- On microaggressions, privilege, and systemic racism: A resource for white people
- Posts
- Part 1 - What it means to be Black in America
Part 1 - What it means to be Black in America
Part 1 in my series ”On microaggressions, privilege, and systemic racism: A resource for white people”
Poll: Black Americans fear more racist attacks after Buffalo shooting, by Silvia Foster-Frau, Arelis R. Hernández, Scott Clement and Emily Guskin, Washington Post, May 21, 2022. ("Two years after George Floyd’s murder, nearly 8 in 10 Black Americans say there has been little or no improvement in how police treat Black people, according to a Washington Post-Ipsos poll." What they do see is an increase in racist dogma among white people, a greater danger to themselves, and little reason for optimism about the future.)
Related editorial: Why Black people are afraid of ‘crazy’ white people, by Jonathan Capehart, Washington Post, Jun. 7, 2022.
Experiencing racism in the day-to-day
On Being A Black Woman In America, by Sarah Jones-Smith, Your Tango, Jun. 13, 2020. ("Black women are judged for every little thing that we do. From the way we wear our hair to the way that we choose to express ourselves, we are constantly policed.")
On Being Not White In America, by Isobel DeBrujah in her What a Witch blog, Mar. 8, 2017. (DeBrujah describes what it's like to walk "a path of coals.")
Student 'slave auctions' illustrate the existence of a hidden culture of domination and subjugation in US schools, by Barbara Harris Combs, The Conversation, Dec. 2, 2022. (This is about "auctions" that still occur with some regularity. Under a Yahoo! News repost, the first commenter adds that such "hijinks" are nothing new. The same commenter also draws a comparison with football leagues' annual drafts.)
TW: This article includes troubling descriptions of recent students' "slave auctions".This White Lady Refused To Be My Assistant; She thought I was below her because I’m Black, by Rebecca Stevens A., Medium.com, Oct. 8, 2022. (A businesswoman relates multiple instances in which white female assistants refused to assist her, even when they were assigned to do so.)
Six Freedoms Black People Do Not Have Under a White Supremacy, by Johnny Silvercloud, Medium.com, May 9, 2020. TW: Two photos of lynchings are buried in the middle of this article. (According to the author, the freedoms denied to Black Americans are: freedom of emotion, freedom of space, freedom of memory, freedom of healing, freedom of self-defense, and the freedom to protect the other five. As he explains each of these freedoms — which white Americans take so much for granted that we don't even name them — the difference between Black America and white America becomes deeply, painfully clear.)
I’m Trying To Use My Husband’s White Privilege A Little Less, by Rebecca Stevens A., Medium.com, Jul. 13, 2022. (The author is a Black woman living in Paris, but she describes the kind of racial incident which occurs all too often in the U.S. Her thoughts on her husband's white privilege are compelling, but I've included it here because of her reaction to the incident.)
'Racial battle fatigue,' community trauma, and other stress-related issues
Racial Discrimination and Telomere Shortening Among African Americans: The Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults (CARDIA) Study, by David H. Chae et al, Health Psychol. Mar. 2020, published online Jan. 13, 2020. ("This study adds to evidence that racial discrimination contributes to accelerated physiologic weathering and health declines among African Americans through its impact on biological systems, including via its effects on telomere attrition.")
RELATED: Telomere length associated with racial bias, discrimination, National Institute on Aging, May 21, 2014.Black Women Were Never Given the Opportunity to Sexually Explore — We’re Reclaiming Our Bodies, by Catasha Gordon, Healthline, Sept. 27, 2021. A discussion of the lasting impact of enslavement on Black women's ability to fully enjoy their own sexuality.)*
How Racism Can Effect Child Development, a downloadable PDF from Harvard University's Center on the Developing Child. ("What could our society look like if racial disparities in health and learning outcomes didn’t exist? According to extensive studies, the U.S. would save billions in health care costs alone. The value of realizing the potential contributions of so many people around the world who are impaired by—or die from—preventable chronic illnesses is enormous, and the human costs are incalculable.")
NOTE: The information in this document is a prime example of intersectionality. Personally, I believe it could best be examined through the lens of critical race theory.Black Masculinity And Mental Health: What Black Men Should Consider About Their Emotional And Mental Wellness, by Maia Niguel Hoskin, Forbes, Mar. 31, 2022. (This article includes a discussion of the impact of Black masculinity norms and stereotypes on the mental health of Black men in America.)
Study reveals staggering toll of being Black in America: 1.6 million excess deaths over 22 years, by By Liz Szabo, KFF Health News, May 16, 2023. ("High mortality rates among Black people have less to do with genetics than with the country’s long history of discrimination, which has undermined educational, housing, and job opportunities for generations of Black people.")
Being Black in America Gave Me Anxiety, So I Left to Save My Life, by Imani Bashir, Self, Jun. 24, 2020. (One woman's story....)
Black women in America are up against a lot, and it’s causing their bodies to weather, by Brianna Holt, Business Insider, Feb. 11, 2023. ("Weathering shows up in myriad ways, for Black women in particular. For instance, if they're pregnant, it affects their fetuses, and their infants. It can cause things like higher infant mortality rates, lower infant birth rates, and just overall impacts to women in child bearing ages.")
17 Feelings It’s Totally Normal to Have as a Black Person in America, by Patia Braithwaite, Self, Jul. 1, 2020. (Published in the wake of George Floyd's murder, this article is written for a Black audience. It presents a gamut of emotions that Black Americans deal with as a result of their shared trauma.)
Why some who experienced police confrontations say Tyre Nichols was right to run, by Curtis Bunn, NBC News, Feb. 2, 2023. (Caution: This article contains graphic descriptions of violent encounters with police. It also links directly to videos of Tyre Nichols' murder.)
Racism as a Stressor for African Americans: A Biopsychosocial Model, by Rodney Clark, Norman B. Anderson, Vernessa R. Clark, and David R. Williams, American Psychologist, Oct. 1999. ("The purpose of this article was to provide a discussion of the potential usefulness of studying the biopsychosocial effects of perceived racism within a stress and coping model.")
CAVEAT: my ADHD is making this kind of text more difficult than usual for me to fully engage with. However, I've digested enough of it to believe it's an important contribution to this list. As a white woman whose physical disability is rooted in chronic, family-related psychological trauma, I get it. My experiences are in no way comparable to that of Black Americans, but they do provide a taste of what happens to the body under ongoing psychological duress. I don't need convincing. I include this article as jumping-off place for those who do.Black Families Have Inherited Trauma, but We Can Change That, by Jacquelyn Clemmons, Healthline, Aug. 26, 2020. (When I look at my life, family, and community, I wonder: which patterns are authentically ours, and which are a result of cultural PTSD?)
What is Epigenetics?, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, May 18, 2022.Epigenetics: The Controversial Science Behind Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities, by Janell Ross, The Atlantic, Mar. 20, 2014. ("Why what we eat, are exposed to, and experience today may shape the health of our descendants tomorrow.")
The Epigenetics of Being Black and Feeling Blue: Understanding African American Vulnerability to Disease, Dr. Darron Smith, Huffington Post, Oct. 14, 2013.
Demanding Black Forgiveness Is Just Another Way To Control Us, by TaLynn Kel, Huffington Post, Aug. 18, 2016.
Black people aren’t making things up: The science behind ‘racial battle fatigue’, by Sam P.K. Collins, ThinkProgress.org, Jun. 19, 2015.
Self Care For People of Color After Psychological Trauma, JustJasmineBlog.com, ca. 2015. This is an article meant for Black readers. It contains excellent insights into the effect of repeated racial incidents on the human brain — an explanation that white readers will benefit from. The comments below are also worth reading.
To Be Female, Anxious and Black, by Angela Neal-Barnett, PhD, Anxiety and Depression Association of America, Apr. 23, 2018.
On being bi-racial and/or multi-racial
The First African-American Spokeswoman for DNC Isn't Black Enough, Says Idiot White Guy, by Meagan Hatcher-Mays, Jezebel.com, Apr. 3, 2013.
Growing up Black
Dreaming in Color, Living in Black and White: Our Own Stories of Gowing Up Black in America, by Laurel Holliday, Simon Pulse, NY, 2003. (In this compelling collection, Black and mixed-race authors recount their personal experiences as children growing up in the Jim Crow era through the post-Civil Rights era. They talk about their struggle to exist within racist environments, both as children and as young adults. Most detail the emotional aftermath of a pivotal racist incident in their formative years. The final story is a stunning demonstration of white fragility in action.)
My copy of this book is an abridged version for young readers. The unabridged version was published in 1999.Black Boys Viewed as Older, Less Innocent Than Whites, Research Finds, American Psychological Association, 2014. ("In one experiment, students rated the innocence of people ranging from infants to 25-year-olds who were black, white or an unidentified race. The students judged children up to 9 years old as equally innocent regardless of race, but considered black children significantly less innocent than other children in every age group beginning at age 10, the researchers found.")
The linked APA article is a summary of The Essence of Innocence: Consequences of Dehumanizing Black Children,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, published online Feb. 24, 2014; Phillip Atiba Goff Ph.D. et al.Growing Up Black: Families Confronting Racism. NBC's Craig Melvin hosts a conversation with families on the realities of parenting black children in America.
Teen shares mom's list of rules to stay safe 'as a young black man, by Meghan Holohan, Today, June 5, 2020. (This list speaks for itself. But at the same time, it's a facet of that difficult conversation ("the talk") faced by every Black parent of a young son — and that's a tragic way for young Black men to grow up.)
New video after Philando Castile shooting: 'Mom... I don't want you to get shooted', by John Bacon, USA TODAY, Jun. 22, 2017. (This is the voice of a child, in the aftermath of the Philando Castile shooting.)
Internalized racism
What Is the Definition of Internalized Racism?: Minorities aren't immune to the negative messages about their racial groups, by Nadra Kareem Nittle, ThoughtCo., Mar., 2021.
Brown in America: A lesson in internalized whiteness, by Larissa Dzegar, Medium.com's "Real Talk: WOC & Allies, May 6, 2017.
Misogynoir
How Megan Thee Stallion’s Shooting Case Reveals Our Internalized Misogynoir, by Janice Gassam Asare, Forbes, Dec. 23, 2022. ("Misogynoir is ... defined as 'the specific hatred, dislike, distrust, and prejudice directed toward Black women.'" Includes a 5-minute audio version.)
White women's tears
Karen Needs to Go To Jail Part 1: A History of Dangerous White Behavior, uploaded Jun. 3, 2020 to Dr. Joy DeGruy's channel on YouTube. (The speakers get off to a bumpy start, but stay with it. Dr. DeGruy outlines the historic, fatal impact of white women's tears, discusses systemic racism, and emphasizes the need for laws against racist 911 calls. Alternately speaking to white and Black audiences, she and her colleague describe what it's like to live in an America where racism and race-based danger are part of their everyday lives. To me, this is a must-see video, not only for the material covered, but because of the conversational, this-is-how-it-is delivery. White people often complain that Black people won't explain things to them; this is your chance to hear it on a deeply human level.)
Becky and Karen aren’t new characters in the story of Race in America., a page of the Deconstructing Karen website. ("...an incomplete and ever-developing history of Becky’s and Karen’s — women quick to blame the easy scapegoat: black men.")
Confront the Weaponization of White Women’s Tears, Nicole Cardoza, Anti-Racism Daily.
Getting Away with Murder: The Murder of Emmett Till, American Experience, PBS.Amy Cooper Knew Exactly What She Was Doing, by Zeba Blay, Huffington Post, May 26, 2020.
On being a Black woman in America
Black Women Often Ignored by Social Justice Movements, American Psychological Association, Jul. 13, 2020.
This article is an overview of “Intersectional Invisibility Revisited: How Group Prototypes Lead to the Erasure and Exclusion of Black Women,” by Stewart M. Coles, MA, and Josh Pasek, PhD, University of Michigan, Jul. 13, 2020.
Voices from the Civil Rights Era
Originally, I gave this section a disheartened title: "Nothing changes," and in many ways, it still seems like that's the case. But as I read further, and as I watched more documentaries from that time, I found inspiration and hope. Black Americans experienced severe — often deadly — hatred and violence during that era. Their courage and determination were immeasurable. We can't let today's racist backlash discourage us. We owe it to those men and women to continue the fight. Otherwise, nothing will change.
"In 1944, Jackie Robinson refused to move to the back of a military bus, when told to by a civilian driver. Jackie was arrested, charged with insubordination, and court-martialed." (Source: "Jackie Robinson 1944 Court-Martial," a page of the Thirteen PBS website, Apr. 12, 2016.)
RELATED: The Court Martial of Jackie Robinson, by Callie Oettinger, The History Reader. (In the most telling way, the word "insolent" drips from the pages of these contemporary report.)
RELATED: Robinson's handling of the bus incident and his subsequent court martial was a deciding factor in Branch Rickey's decision to recruit him for the Brooklyn Dodgers. ("Robinson was on Rickey’s radar even before he officially scouted him. His background of restrained protest, allowing demonstrations and the court to determine his fate in the Army, appealed to Rickey. In addition to being an Army officer, Rickey was drawn to Robinson because of his collegiate success. Robinson was an educated, talented and determined young man who had demonstrated resolve in volatile situations. He was the type of man that Rickey believed would be successful if given the chance.") Source: When Did Jackie Robinson Integrate Baseball and Why Is It Important, a page from the DailyHistory.org website.American Experience's "Eyes on the Prize: America's Civil Rights Years 1954–1965" begins here, on archive.org. (This is the first half of PBS's award-winning series. It covers the Civil Rights Movement, beginning with the murder of Emmett Till and the Montgomery bus boycotts, continuing through to the 1965 Selma to Montgomery marches.)
"Eyes on the Prize" aired first in 1988, and again in 2006. Archive.org has made it permanently available to anyone who wants to watch it . The site offers download options, as well.Eyes on the Prize Part 2: "America at the Racial Crossroads 1965–1985": continues here.
A PERSONAL NOTE: Far from being a mere collection of dusty archive footage, "Eyes on the Prize" is the compelling story of the Civil Rights Era's early, often violent years — and the men and women who risked everything in their quest for equal rights. I sat down to watch it, thinking I'd only review some of the news footage I watched on my family's black-and-white TV. Hours later, I find myself completely immersed and learning details I never heard before. I have no regrets about what I should have been doing instead. This was far more important.American Experience's "The American Diplomat" is an important addendum to the story of America's civil rights movement. (This is an archive.org upload.)
For more information about this episode (including a transcript), go here.
See also 100 Years of Black Diplomats."Freedom on My Mind", on archive.org. (From the Wikipedia description: This video is "the story of the Mississippi voter registration movement of 1961 to 1964.")
"American Experience - The Blinding of Isaac Woodard", WPBS, Watertown, NY. ("How a Horrific Incident of Racial Violence Became a Powerful Catalyst for the Civil Rights Movement." "The Blinding of Isaac Woodard" is a searing look at violence in the Jim Crow South.)
FOR MORE INFORMATION: "The Blinding of Isaac Woodard" description, including transcript. (Moved by the Woodard case, Judge Julius Waties Waring and Harry Truman both became staunch anti-racists, determined to do what they could for Civil rights — regardless of the personal and professional cost.)Judge Julius Waties Waring was a heroic role model for anti-racists.
Vilified in 1940s, Federal Judge Is Honored As Civil Rights Hero, a page of the United States Courts website, Apr. 14, 2014.How The Son Of A Confederate Soldier Became A Civil Rights Hero, by the NPR staff, NPR, Apr. 10, 2014.
The Economist's review of my book reveals how white people still refuse to believe black people about being black, by Edward E. Baptist, The Guardian, Sept. 7, 2014. (This is Baptist's scathing rebuttal of The Economist's review of his then-recently published The Half Has Never Been Told: Slavery and the Making of American Capitalism. Unsurprisingly, comments under the linked Good Reads review continue the debate over Baptist's reliance on the contemporary testimony of enslaved persons. I include The Guardian post and comments because to me, the counter-opinions sound like a continuation of broader white reluctance to believe Black statements about pretty much everything. Doctors still refuse to believe Black patients about pain levels and medical symptoms. White people continue to blow off Black stories of microaggressions and outright racist acts. In that vein, historians discount the value of testimony about slavery — given by long-dead Black men and women who were actually enslaved — on grounds that it's merely anecdotal and doesn't represent the broader picture.)
Full disclosure: I haven't yet read The Half Has Never Been Told. It will be some time before I get a chance to. but it's definitely on my list.This is what ‘whitelash’ looks like, by John Blake, CNN, Nov. 19, 2016. (A comparison of the backlash that followed Barack Obama's presidency and the end of Reconstruction.)
James Baldwin: How to Cool It, Esquire, Aug. 2, 2017. (A reprint of Esquire's "landmark 1968 Q&A on race in America. In Esquire's July 1968 issue, published just after the death of Martin Luther King, Jr., the magazine talked to James Baldwin about the state of race relations in the country. We've republished the interview in full—and his words are incredibly relevant today." Another copy can be found here, on Portside. ""
Continue to Part 2: Systemic racism and entrenched social bias
Return to main index: On microaggressions, privilege, and systemic racism: A resource for white people